Working Paper: ‘Optimal’ Pollution Abatement – Whose Benefits Matter, and How Much?
Paper Number: 2002-05
Document Date: 04/02/2004
Author(s): Wayne B. Gray and Ronald J. Shadbegian
Subject Area(s): Air Pollution; Water Pollution; Environmental Policy
Keywords: environmental regulation; environmental justice; pollution abatement benefits; transboundary pollution
Abstract: In this paper we examine the allocation of environmental regulatory effort across U.S. pulp and paper mills, looking at measures of regulatory activity (inspections and enforcement actions) and levels of air and water pollution from those mills. We combine measures of the marginal benefits of air and water pollution abatement at each mill with measures of the characteristics of the people living near the mill. This allows for the possibility that some people may count less in the calculations of regulators (and polluters), either because they have less political clout or because they live in another jurisdiction. We perform the analyses using a plant-level panel data set with approximately 300 pulp and paper mills from 1985-1997. We find support for the importance of both the benefits from pollution abatement and political factors related to the people affected, particularly related to the amount of air and water pollution being emitted. The results suggest substantial differences in the weights assigned to different types of people. In some models the benefits received by out-of-state people seem to count only half as much as benefits received in-state, but their weight increases if the bordering state’s Congressmen are strongly pro-environment. A few of these variables are also associated with greater regulatory activity being directed towards the plant, although those results are less consistent with our hypotheses than the pollution results. One set of results was consistently contrary to expectations: plants with more nonwhites nearby emit less pollution. Some of our results might be due to endogenous sorting of people based on pollution, but an attempt to examine this using the local population turnover rate found evidence of sorting for only one of four pollutants.
Published: Gray, Wayne B. and Ronald J. Shadbegian. 2004. "Optimal Pollution Abatement – Whose Benefits Matter, and How Much?," Journal of Environmental Economics and Management, 47(3): 510–534.
This paper is part of the Environmental Economics Working Paper Series.